10.) Chris Jericho (2016)
Best Match
WWE Fastlane 2016
AJ Styles def. Chris Jericho
****
Best Match
WWE Fastlane 2016
AJ Styles def. Chris Jericho
****
9.) Bully Ray (2011-2013)
Best Match
TNA Slammiversary IX
Bully Ray def. AJ Styles [Last Man Standing Match]
***3/4
Best Match
TNA Slammiversary IX
Bully Ray def. AJ Styles [Last Man Standing Match]
***3/4
8.) Shinsuke Nakamura (2016-2018)
Best Match
NJPW Wreslte Kingdom 10
Shinsuke Nakamura(c) def. AJ Styles [IWGP Intercontinental Championship]
*****
Best Match
NJPW Wreslte Kingdom 10
Shinsuke Nakamura(c) def. AJ Styles [IWGP Intercontinental Championship]
*****
7.) Undertaker (2020)
Best Match
WWE WrestleMania 36 (Night 1)
Undertaker def. AJ Styles [Boneyard Match]
****1/2
Best Match
WWE WrestleMania 36 (Night 1)
Undertaker def. AJ Styles [Boneyard Match]
****1/2
6.) Jeff Jarrett (2003-2004; 2010-2011)
Best Match
TNA 6/11/03
AJ Styles def. Jeff Jarrett(c) [NWA Championship]
***3/4
Best Match
TNA 6/11/03
AJ Styles def. Jeff Jarrett(c) [NWA Championship]
***3/4
5.) Bryan Danielson/Daniel Bryan (2003-2007; 2018-2019)
Best Match
WWE SmackDown 6/12/20
AJ Styles def. Daniel Bryan [Vacant Intercontinental Championship]
*****
Best Match
WWE SmackDown 6/12/20
AJ Styles def. Daniel Bryan [Vacant Intercontinental Championship]
*****
4.) Kurt Angle (2008-2013)
Best Match
TNA Hard Justice 2008
AJ Styles def. Kurt Angle [Last Man Standing Match]
****1/2
Best Match
TNA Hard Justice 2008
AJ Styles def. Kurt Angle [Last Man Standing Match]
****1/2
3.) John Cena (2016-2017)
Best Match
WWE Royal Rumble 2017
John Cena def. AJ Styles(c) [WWE Championship]
*****
Best Match
WWE Royal Rumble 2017
John Cena def. AJ Styles(c) [WWE Championship]
*****
2.) Christopher Daniels (2005-2012)
Best Match
TNA Against All Odds 2005
AJ Styles(c) def. Christopher Daniels [X-Division Championship]
*****
Best Match
TNA Against All Odds 2005
AJ Styles(c) def. Christopher Daniels [X-Division Championship]
*****
1.) Samoa Joe (2005-2009; 2018)
Best Match
TNA Turning Point 2005
Samoa Joe def. AJ Styles(c) [X-Division Championship]
****3/4
Best Match
TNA Turning Point 2005
Samoa Joe def. AJ Styles(c) [X-Division Championship]
****3/4