WWE Extreme Rules 2009
- Kofi Kingston(c) def. MVP, William Regal, & Matt Hardy [United States Championship] (**1/2)
- Chris Jericho def. Rey Mysterio(c) [Intercontinental Championship; No Holds Barred Match] (****1/4)
- CM Punk def. Umaga [Strap Match] (*1/2)
- Tommy Dreamer def. Christian(c) & Jack Swagger [ECW Championship] (***1/4)
- Santina def. Vickie Guerrero [Hog Pen Match] (DUD)
- Batista def. Randy Orton(c) [WWE Championship; Steel Cage Match] (*1/4)
- John Cena def. Big Show [Submission Match] (*)
- Jeff Hardy def. Edge(c) [World Championship; Ladder Match] (****1/2)
- CM Punk def. Jeff Hardy(c) [CM Punk Cashes In] (N/A)
Overall: 7/10
- Kofi Kingston(c) def. MVP, William Regal, & Matt Hardy [United States Championship] (**1/2)
- Chris Jericho def. Rey Mysterio(c) [Intercontinental Championship; No Holds Barred Match] (****1/4)
- CM Punk def. Umaga [Strap Match] (*1/2)
- Tommy Dreamer def. Christian(c) & Jack Swagger [ECW Championship] (***1/4)
- Santina def. Vickie Guerrero [Hog Pen Match] (DUD)
- Batista def. Randy Orton(c) [WWE Championship; Steel Cage Match] (*1/4)
- John Cena def. Big Show [Submission Match] (*)
- Jeff Hardy def. Edge(c) [World Championship; Ladder Match] (****1/2)
- CM Punk def. Jeff Hardy(c) [CM Punk Cashes In] (N/A)
Overall: 7/10
WWE Extreme Rules 2010
- Hart Dynasty won Gauntlet Match [#1 Contender Match] (**)
- CM Punk def. Rey Mysterio [If CM Punk Loses, He Loses His Hair] (****)
- JTG def. Shad [Strap Match] (*1/2)
- Jack Swagger(c) def. Randy Orton [World Championship; Extreme Rules Match] (***1/2)
- Sheamus def. Triple H [Street Fight] (***1/4)
- Beth Phoenix def. Micheal McCool(c) [Womens Championship; Extreme Makeover Match] (**)
- Edge def. Chris Jericho [Steel Cage Match] (****)
- John Cena(c) def. Batista [WWE Championship; Last Man Standing] (****)
Overall: 7/10
- Hart Dynasty won Gauntlet Match [#1 Contender Match] (**)
- CM Punk def. Rey Mysterio [If CM Punk Loses, He Loses His Hair] (****)
- JTG def. Shad [Strap Match] (*1/2)
- Jack Swagger(c) def. Randy Orton [World Championship; Extreme Rules Match] (***1/2)
- Sheamus def. Triple H [Street Fight] (***1/4)
- Beth Phoenix def. Micheal McCool(c) [Womens Championship; Extreme Makeover Match] (**)
- Edge def. Chris Jericho [Steel Cage Match] (****)
- John Cena(c) def. Batista [WWE Championship; Last Man Standing] (****)
Overall: 7/10
WWE Extreme Rules 2011
- Randy Orton def. CM Punk [Last Man Standing] (****)
- Kofi Kingston def. Sheamus(c) [United States Championship; Tables Match] (***)
- Micheal Cole/Jack Swagger def. Jerry Lawler/Jim Ross [Country Woopen Match] (DUD)
- Rey Mysterio def. Cody Rhodes [Falls Count Anywhere] (****)
- Layla def. Micheal McCool [Loser Leaves WWE Match] (**)
- Christian def. Alberto Del Rio [World Championship; Ladder Match] (****1/4)
- Big Show/Kane(c) def. The Corre [WWE Tag Team Championships; Lumberjack Match] (**)
- John Cena def. Miz(c) & John Morrison [WWE Championship; Steel Cage Match] (****)
Overall: 8/10
- Randy Orton def. CM Punk [Last Man Standing] (****)
- Kofi Kingston def. Sheamus(c) [United States Championship; Tables Match] (***)
- Micheal Cole/Jack Swagger def. Jerry Lawler/Jim Ross [Country Woopen Match] (DUD)
- Rey Mysterio def. Cody Rhodes [Falls Count Anywhere] (****)
- Layla def. Micheal McCool [Loser Leaves WWE Match] (**)
- Christian def. Alberto Del Rio [World Championship; Ladder Match] (****1/4)
- Big Show/Kane(c) def. The Corre [WWE Tag Team Championships; Lumberjack Match] (**)
- John Cena def. Miz(c) & John Morrison [WWE Championship; Steel Cage Match] (****)
Overall: 8/10
WWE Extreme Rules 2012
- Randy Orton def. Kane [Falls Count Anywhere] (***1/2)
- Brodus Clay def. Dolph Ziggler (**)
- Cody Rhodes def. Big Show(c) [Intercontinental Championship; Tables Match] (**)
- Sheamus(c) def. Daniel Bryan [World Championship; 2 out of 3 Falls] (****1/2)
- Ryback def. Locals [2 on 1 Handicap] (DUD)
- CM Punk(c) def. Chris Jericho [WWE Championship; Chicago Street Fight] (****1/2)
- Layla def. Nikki Bella(c) [Divas Championship] (N/A)
- John Cena def. Brock Lesnar [Extreme Rules Match] (****1/2)
Overall: 8/10
- Randy Orton def. Kane [Falls Count Anywhere] (***1/2)
- Brodus Clay def. Dolph Ziggler (**)
- Cody Rhodes def. Big Show(c) [Intercontinental Championship; Tables Match] (**)
- Sheamus(c) def. Daniel Bryan [World Championship; 2 out of 3 Falls] (****1/2)
- Ryback def. Locals [2 on 1 Handicap] (DUD)
- CM Punk(c) def. Chris Jericho [WWE Championship; Chicago Street Fight] (****1/2)
- Layla def. Nikki Bella(c) [Divas Championship] (N/A)
- John Cena def. Brock Lesnar [Extreme Rules Match] (****1/2)
Overall: 8/10
WWE Extreme Rules 2013
- Chris Jericho def. Fandango (***)
- Dean Ambrose def. Kofi Kingston(c) [United States Championship] (***1/4)
- Sheamus def. Mark Henry [Strap Match] (**1/2)
- Alberto Del Rio def. Jack Swagger [#1 Contender Match; "I Quit" Match] (***)
- The Shield def. Team Hell No(c) [WWE Tag Team Championships; Tornado Match] (***3/4)
- Randy Orton def. Big Show [Extreme Rules Match] (***1/2)
- John Cena(c) vs. Ryback Ended In No Contest [WWE Championship; Last Man Standing Match] (***3/4)
- Brock Lesnar def. Triple H [Steel Cage Match] (****)
Overall: 8/10
- Chris Jericho def. Fandango (***)
- Dean Ambrose def. Kofi Kingston(c) [United States Championship] (***1/4)
- Sheamus def. Mark Henry [Strap Match] (**1/2)
- Alberto Del Rio def. Jack Swagger [#1 Contender Match; "I Quit" Match] (***)
- The Shield def. Team Hell No(c) [WWE Tag Team Championships; Tornado Match] (***3/4)
- Randy Orton def. Big Show [Extreme Rules Match] (***1/2)
- John Cena(c) vs. Ryback Ended In No Contest [WWE Championship; Last Man Standing Match] (***3/4)
- Brock Lesnar def. Triple H [Steel Cage Match] (****)
Overall: 8/10
WWE Extreme Rules 2014
- Cesaro def. RVD & Jack Swagger [Elimination Match] (***1/2)
- Alexander Rusev def. R-Truth/Xavior Woods (*)
- Bad News Barrett def. Big E(c) [Intercontinental Championship] (***)
- The Shield def. Evolution (****1/2)
- Bray Wyatt def. John Cena [Steel Cage Match] (**1/2)
- Paige(c) def. Tamina Snuka [Divas Championship] (***)
- Daniel Bryan(c) def. Kane [WWE World Championship; Extreme Rules Match] (****1/4)
Overall: 8/10
- Cesaro def. RVD & Jack Swagger [Elimination Match] (***1/2)
- Alexander Rusev def. R-Truth/Xavior Woods (*)
- Bad News Barrett def. Big E(c) [Intercontinental Championship] (***)
- The Shield def. Evolution (****1/2)
- Bray Wyatt def. John Cena [Steel Cage Match] (**1/2)
- Paige(c) def. Tamina Snuka [Divas Championship] (***)
- Daniel Bryan(c) def. Kane [WWE World Championship; Extreme Rules Match] (****1/4)
Overall: 8/10
WWE Extreme Rules 2015
- Dean Ambrose def. Luke Harper [Chicago Street Fight] (**)
- Dolph Ziggler def. Sheamus [Kiss Me Arse Match] (***1/4)
- New Day def. Cesaro/Tyson Kidd(c) [WWE Tag Team Championships] (***1/2)
- John Cena(c) def. Rusev [United States Championship; Russian Chain Match] (**)
- Nikki Bella(c) def. Naomi [Divas Championship] (*)
- Roman Reigns def. Big Show [Last Man Standing Match] (***1/2)
- Seth Rollins(c) def. Randy Orton [WWE Championship; Steel Cage Match] (***)
Overall: 6/10
- Dean Ambrose def. Luke Harper [Chicago Street Fight] (**)
- Dolph Ziggler def. Sheamus [Kiss Me Arse Match] (***1/4)
- New Day def. Cesaro/Tyson Kidd(c) [WWE Tag Team Championships] (***1/2)
- John Cena(c) def. Rusev [United States Championship; Russian Chain Match] (**)
- Nikki Bella(c) def. Naomi [Divas Championship] (*)
- Roman Reigns def. Big Show [Last Man Standing Match] (***1/2)
- Seth Rollins(c) def. Randy Orton [WWE Championship; Steel Cage Match] (***)
Overall: 6/10
WWE Extreme Rules 2016
SETH ROLLINS RETURNS!
- The Club def. Usos [Tornado Match] (***)
- Rusev def. Kalisto(c) [United States Championship] (***)
- New Day(c) def. The Vaudevillains [WWE Tag Team Championships] (**3/4)
- Miz(c) def. Kevin Owens, Sami Zayn, & Cesaro [Intercontinental Championship] (****1/2)
- Dean Ambrose def. Chris Jericho [Asylum Match] (**1/2)
- Charlotte(c) def. Natalya [Women's Championship; Submission Match] (**)
- Roman Reigns(c) def. AJ Styles [WWE Championship; Extreme Rules Match] (****1/2)
Overall: 7/10
SETH ROLLINS RETURNS!
- The Club def. Usos [Tornado Match] (***)
- Rusev def. Kalisto(c) [United States Championship] (***)
- New Day(c) def. The Vaudevillains [WWE Tag Team Championships] (**3/4)
- Miz(c) def. Kevin Owens, Sami Zayn, & Cesaro [Intercontinental Championship] (****1/2)
- Dean Ambrose def. Chris Jericho [Asylum Match] (**1/2)
- Charlotte(c) def. Natalya [Women's Championship; Submission Match] (**)
- Roman Reigns(c) def. AJ Styles [WWE Championship; Extreme Rules Match] (****1/2)
Overall: 7/10
WWE Extreme Rules 2017
- Miz def. Dean Ambrose(c) [Intercontinental Championship; Title Changes Hand By DQ] (***3/4)
- Sasha Banks/Rich Swann def. Alicia Fox/Noam Dar [Mix Tag Team Match] (**1/2)
- Alexa Bliss(c) def. Bayley [RAW Women's Championship; Kendo Stick On A Pole Match] (DUD)
- Cesaro/Sheamus def. Hardyz(c) [RAW Tag Team Championships; Steel Cage Match] (***1/2)
- Neville(c) def. Austin Aries [Cruiserweight Championship; Submission Match] (***1/2)
- Samoa Joe won Extreme Rules Fatal 5 Way Match [#1 Contender For Universal Championship] (****1/4)
Overall: 7/10
- Miz def. Dean Ambrose(c) [Intercontinental Championship; Title Changes Hand By DQ] (***3/4)
- Sasha Banks/Rich Swann def. Alicia Fox/Noam Dar [Mix Tag Team Match] (**1/2)
- Alexa Bliss(c) def. Bayley [RAW Women's Championship; Kendo Stick On A Pole Match] (DUD)
- Cesaro/Sheamus def. Hardyz(c) [RAW Tag Team Championships; Steel Cage Match] (***1/2)
- Neville(c) def. Austin Aries [Cruiserweight Championship; Submission Match] (***1/2)
- Samoa Joe won Extreme Rules Fatal 5 Way Match [#1 Contender For Universal Championship] (****1/4)
Overall: 7/10
WWE Extreme Rules 2018
- B-Team def. Deleters Of Worlds(c) [RAW Tag Team Championships] (**1/4)
- Finn Balor def. Baron Corbin (*1/4)
- Carmella(c) def. Asuka [SmackDown Women's Championship] (DUD)
- Shinsuke Nakamura def. Jeff Hardy(c) [United States Championship] (N/A)
- Kevin Owens def. Braun Strowman [Steel Cage Match] (**)
- Bludgeon Brothers(c) def. Team Hell No [SmackDown Tag Team Championships] (**3/4)
- Bobby Lashley def. Roman Reigns (***1/4)
- Alexa Bliss(c) vs. Nia Jax [RAW Women's Championship; Extreme Rules Match] (*1/2)
- AJ Styles(c) def. Rusev [WWE Championship] (***3/4)
- Dolph Ziggler(c) def. Seth Rollins [Intercontinental Championship; Iron Man Match] (***)
Overall: 3/10
- B-Team def. Deleters Of Worlds(c) [RAW Tag Team Championships] (**1/4)
- Finn Balor def. Baron Corbin (*1/4)
- Carmella(c) def. Asuka [SmackDown Women's Championship] (DUD)
- Shinsuke Nakamura def. Jeff Hardy(c) [United States Championship] (N/A)
- Kevin Owens def. Braun Strowman [Steel Cage Match] (**)
- Bludgeon Brothers(c) def. Team Hell No [SmackDown Tag Team Championships] (**3/4)
- Bobby Lashley def. Roman Reigns (***1/4)
- Alexa Bliss(c) vs. Nia Jax [RAW Women's Championship; Extreme Rules Match] (*1/2)
- AJ Styles(c) def. Rusev [WWE Championship] (***3/4)
- Dolph Ziggler(c) def. Seth Rollins [Intercontinental Championship; Iron Man Match] (***)
Overall: 3/10
WWE Extreme Rules 2019
- Undertaker/Roman Reigns def. Shane McMahon/Drew McIntyre [No Holds Barred Match] (***3/4)
- The Revival(c) def. Usos [RAW Tag Team Championships] (***1/4)
- Aleister Black def. Cesaro (****)
- Bayley(c) def. Alexa Bliss/Nikki Cross [SmackDown Women's Championship; 2 On 1 Handicap Match] (*1/4)
- Braun Strowman def. Bobby Lashley [Last Man Standing Match] (***1/2)
- New Day def. Daniel Bryan/Rowan(c) & Heavy Machinery [SmackDown Tag Team Championships] (****)
- AJ Styles def. Ricochet(c) [United States Championship] (****1/4)
- Kevin Owens def. Dolph Ziggler (N/A)
- Kofi Kingston(c) def. Samoa Joe [WWE Championship] (***)
- Seth Rollins(c)/Becky Lynch(c) def. Baron Corbin/Lacey Evans [Winner Takes All; Extreme Rules Match] (***1/2)
- Brock Lesnar def. Seth Rollins(c) [Universal Championship; Cash-In Match] (N/A)
Overall: 9/10
- Undertaker/Roman Reigns def. Shane McMahon/Drew McIntyre [No Holds Barred Match] (***3/4)
- The Revival(c) def. Usos [RAW Tag Team Championships] (***1/4)
- Aleister Black def. Cesaro (****)
- Bayley(c) def. Alexa Bliss/Nikki Cross [SmackDown Women's Championship; 2 On 1 Handicap Match] (*1/4)
- Braun Strowman def. Bobby Lashley [Last Man Standing Match] (***1/2)
- New Day def. Daniel Bryan/Rowan(c) & Heavy Machinery [SmackDown Tag Team Championships] (****)
- AJ Styles def. Ricochet(c) [United States Championship] (****1/4)
- Kevin Owens def. Dolph Ziggler (N/A)
- Kofi Kingston(c) def. Samoa Joe [WWE Championship] (***)
- Seth Rollins(c)/Becky Lynch(c) def. Baron Corbin/Lacey Evans [Winner Takes All; Extreme Rules Match] (***1/2)
- Brock Lesnar def. Seth Rollins(c) [Universal Championship; Cash-In Match] (N/A)
Overall: 9/10
WWE The Horror Show At Extreme Rules 2020
WWE 2020 = WCW 2000
- Cesaro/Shinuske Nakamura def. New Day(c) [SmackDown Tag Team Championships; Tables Match] (**3/4)
- Bayley(c) def. Nikki Cross (**)
- Seth Rollins def. Rey Mysterio [Eye For An Eye Match] (***1/2)
- Asuka(c) vs. Sasha Banks Ended In No Contest [RAW Women's Championship] (***1/4)
- Drew McIntyre(c) def. Dolph Ziggler [WWE Championship; Drew Loses Title By DQ] (***)
- Braun Strowman(c) vs. Bray Wyatt Ended In No Contest [Universal Championship; Swamp Fight] (N/A)
Overall: 4/10
WWE 2020 = WCW 2000
- Cesaro/Shinuske Nakamura def. New Day(c) [SmackDown Tag Team Championships; Tables Match] (**3/4)
- Bayley(c) def. Nikki Cross (**)
- Seth Rollins def. Rey Mysterio [Eye For An Eye Match] (***1/2)
- Asuka(c) vs. Sasha Banks Ended In No Contest [RAW Women's Championship] (***1/4)
- Drew McIntyre(c) def. Dolph Ziggler [WWE Championship; Drew Loses Title By DQ] (***)
- Braun Strowman(c) vs. Bray Wyatt Ended In No Contest [Universal Championship; Swamp Fight] (N/A)
Overall: 4/10